14/12/2011 - 6ª extra - votação parecer LOA
Aos quatorze dias do mês de dezembro de dois mil e onze, às dez horas e zero minutos, no Plenário Tiradentes da Assembleia Legislativa do Estado de São Paulo, realizou-se a Sexta Reunião Extraordinária da Comissão de Finanças, Orçamento e Planejamento, da Primeira Sessão Legislativa da Décima Sétima Legislatura, sob presidência do Deputado Mauro Bragato. Presentes as Senhoras Deputadas Vanessa Damo, Ana Perugini, Maria Lúcia Amary, Regina Gonçalves e os Senhores Deputados Carlos Bezerra, Mauro Bragato, Luiz Cláudio Marcolino, Simão Pedro, Estevam Galvão, Orlando Bolçone (membros efetivos) e o Senhor Deputado Alex Manente (membro substituto). Ausente o Senhor Deputado Vitor Sapienza. Havendo número regimental, o Senhor Presidente declarou aberta a reunião. Presentes, ainda, no decorrer dos trabalhos, os Senhores Deputados Samuel Moreira, Enio Tatto, Aldo Demarchi e Itamar Borges. Por solicitação do Deputado Luiz Cláudio Marcolino, a ata da reunião anterior foi lida, colocada em votação e aprovada. Em pauta, para deliberação, o voto da relatora, Senhora Deputada Maria Lucia Amary, ao PL 954/11, que orça a receita e fixa a despesa do Estado para 2012: voto favorável ao projeto, à emenda nº 115, às emendas "A" e "B" e às seguintes emendas, na forma das subemendas nºs 1 a 13: 00054, 00059, 00060, 00061, 00062, 00063, 00064, 00065, 00066, 00067, 00068, 00069, 00070, 00071, 00072, 00073, 00074, 00075, 00076, 00077, 00078, 00079, 00080, 00081, 00082, 00083, 00084, 00085, 00095, 00138, 00175, 00176, 00179, 00181, 00185, 00187, 00189, 00190, 00191, 00192, 00193, 00194, 00195, 00196, 00197, 00198, 00199, 00200, 00201, 00202, 00215, 00216, 00217, 00218, 00222, 00223, 00224, 00225, 00226, 00227, 00228, 00231, 00233, 00234, 00235, 00236, 00237, 00238, 00239, 00240, 00241, 00242, 00243, 00244, 00247, 00251, 00252, 00256, 00260, 00265, 00266, 00267, 00269, 00271, 00275, 00277, 00278, 00280, 00281, 00282, 00284, 00285, 00286, 00287, 00289, 00290, 00291, 00292, 00296, 00297, 00300, 00302, 00304, 00305, 00314, 00390, 00391, 00392, 00393, 00397, 00398, 00399, 00400, 00401, 00408, 00412, 00413, 00414, 00415, 00416, 00417, 00420, 00422, 00426, 00435, 00436, 00437, 00441, 00443, 00446, 00461, 00462, 00466, 00468, 00469, 00471, 00501, 00528, 00532, 00536, 00540, 00545, 00590, 00596, 00598, 00612, 00613, 00623, 00632, 00633, 00635, 00645, 00646, 00647, 00652, 00655, 00671, 00680, 00705, 00743, 00746, 00782, 00785, 00788, 00789, 00796, 00798, 00831, 00833, 00859, 00861, 00864, 00865, 00866, 00867, 00868, 00869, 00871, 00924, 00928, 00934, 00946, 00959, 00964, 00966, 00967, 00971, 00972, 00975, 00977, 00980, 00984, 01109, 01112, 01113, 01126, 01136, 01140, 01145, 01150, 01157, 01158, 01159, 01164, 01165, 01166, 01167, 01169, 01176, 01178, 01182, 01184, 01185, 01186, 01198, 01205, 01206, 01207, 01208, 01209, 01217, 01249, 01336, 01338, 01340, 01342, 01357, 01367, 01421, 01446, 01455, 01500, 01501, 01502, 01503, 01504, 01505, 01506, 01507, 01508, 01509, 01510, 01511, 01512, 01513, 01514, 01515, 01516, 01517, 01518, 01519, 01520, 01521, 01522, 01523, 01524, 01525, 01526, 01527, 01528, 01529, 01530, 01531, 01532, 01533, 01534, 01535, 01536, 01537, 01538, 01539, 01540, 01541, 01542, 01543, 01544, 01545, 01546, 01547, 01548, 01549, 01550, 01551, 01552, 01553, 01554, 01555, 01556, 01557, 01558, 01559, 01560, 01561, 01562, 01563, 01564, 01565, 01566, 01567, 01568, 01569, 01570, 01571, 01606, 01610, 01654, 01655, 01656, 01665, 01671, 01683, 01688, 01689, 01693, 01694, 01695, 01696, 01697, 01698, 01699, 01700, 01701, 01702, 01703, 01704, 01705, 01706, 01707, 01708, 01709, 01710, 01711, 01712, 01713, 01714, 01715, 01716, 01717, 01718, 01719, 01720, 01721, 01722, 01723, 01724, 01725, 01726, 01727, 01728, 01729, 01730, 01731, 01732, 01733, 01734, 01735, 01736, 01737, 01738, 01739, 01740, 01741, 01742, 01743, 01744, 01745, 01746, 01747, 01748, 01749, 01750, 01751, 01752, 01753, 01754, 01755, 01756, 01757, 01758, 01759, 01760, 01761, 01762, 01763, 01764, 01765, 01766, 01767, 01768, 01769, 01770, 01771, 01772, 01773, 01774, 01775, 01776, 01777, 01778, 01779, 01780, 01781, 01782, 01783, 01784, 01785, 01786, 01787, 01788, 01789, 01790, 01791, 01792, 01793, 01794, 01795, 01796, 01797, 01798, 01799, 01800, 01801, 01802, 01803, 01804, 01805, 01806, 01807, 01808, 01809, 01810, 01811, 01812, 01813, 01814, 01815, 01816, 01817, 01818, 01819, 01820, 01821, 01822, 01823, 01824, 01825, 01826, 01827, 01828, 01829, 01830, 01831, 01832, 01833, 01834, 01954, 01959, 01963, 01987, 01988, 01989, 01990, 01991, 01992, 01993, 01994, 01995, 01996, 01997, 01998, 01999, 02000, 02001, 02002, 02003, 02004, 02005, 02006, 02007, 02008, 02009, 02010, 02011, 02012, 02013, 02014, 02015, 02016, 02017, 02018, 02019, 02020, 02021, 02022, 02023, 02024, 02025, 02026, 02027, 02028, 02029, 02030, 02031, 02032, 02033, 02034, 02035, 02036, 02037, 02038, 02039, 02040, 02041, 02042, 02043, 02044, 02045, 02046, 02047, 02048, 02049, 02050, 02051, 02052, 02053, 02054, 02055, 02056, 02057, 02058, 02086, 02087, 02088, 02089, 02090, 02091, 02092, 02093, 02094, 02095, 02110, 02158, 02172, 02187, 02199, 02208, 02253, 02293, 02297, 02300, 02341, 02343, 02348, 02359, 02361, 02362, 02367, 02369, 02377, 02379, 02382, 02383, 02384, 02392, 02396, 02405, 02410, 02412, 02415, 02416, 02421, 02422, 02426, 02430, 02437, 02439, 02443, 02444, 02446, 02448, 02449, 02450, 02451, 02453, 02454, 02455, 02457, 02458, 02459, 02460, 02463, 02465, 02467, 02468, 02471, 02474, 02476, 02477, 02479, 02480, 02481, 02482, 02483, 02484, 02485, 02486, 02487, 02488, 02489, 02490, 02491, 02492, 02493, 02494, 02495, 02496, 02498, 02499, 02500, 02501, 02502, 02504, 02505, 02506, 02507, 02508, 02509, 02510, 02514, 02516, 02517, 02520, 02521, 02522, 02523, 02524, 02525, 02526, 02527, 02528, 02529, 02530, 02531, 02532, 02533, 02534, 02536, 02538, 02539, 02540, 02541, 02542, 02543, 02546, 02547, 02548, 02549, 02550, 02551, 02552, 02553, 02554, 02555, 02556, 02557, 02558, 02559, 02561, 02562, 02563, 02564, 02565, 02566, 02567, 02568, 02569, 02570, 02572, 02573, 02574, 02575, 02576, 02577, 02578, 02579, 02580, 02581, 02582, 02583, 02585, 02590, 02591, 02593, 02594, 02595, 02596, 02597, 02598, 02599, 02600, 02601, 02602, 02603, 02604, 02605, 02606, 02607, 02608, 02609, 02610, 02611, 02612, 02613, 02615, 02617, 02618, 02620, 02621, 02622, 02623, 02624, 02625, 02626, 02627, 02628, 02629, 02630, 02631, 02633, 02634, 02635, 02636, 02637, 02638, 02640, 02641, 02642, 02643, 02644, 02645, 02646, 02647, 02648, 02649, 02650, 02651, 02652, 02653, 02654, 02655, 02656, 02657, 02658, 02659, 02660, 02661, 02663, 02664, 02666, 02667, 02668, 02669, 02670, 02671, 02672, 02673, 02674, 02675, 02676, 02677, 02678, 02679, 02681, 02682, 02684, 02685, 02686, 02687, 02688, 02692, 02693, 02695, 02696, 02697, 02698, 02701, 02703, 02704, 02706, 02707, 02708, 02709, 02710, 02711, 02712, 02713, 02714, 02715, 02716, 02717, 02718, 02719, 02720, 02721, 02722, 02723, 02724, 02725, 02726, 02727, 02728, 02729, 02730, 02731, 02732, 02733, 02734, 02735, 02736, 02737, 02738, 02739, 02740, 02741, 02857, 02858, 02859, 02860, 02878, 02881, 02890, 02891, 02892, 02893, 02927, 02928, 02929, 02930, 02931, 02932, 02933, 02934, 02939, 02940, 02941, 02942, 02943, 02944, 02945, 02946, 02947, 02948, 02949, 02950, 02951, 02952, 02953, 02954, 02955, 02956, 02957, 02958, 02959, 02960, 02961, 02962, 02963, 02964, 02965, 02966, 02967, 02968, 02969, 02970, 02971, 02972, 02979, 02980, 02981, 02982, 02986, 03005, 03017, 03021, 03026, 03032, 03034, 03037, 03038, 03040, 03044, 03045, 03049, 03052, 03054, 03059, 03060, 03061, 03063, 03064, 03065, 03067, 03070, 03072, 03073, 03074, 03075, 03076, 03077, 03088, 03097, 03098, 03100, 03101, 03102, 03145, 03146, 03159, 03160, 03161, 03162, 03163, 03164, 03187, 03188, 03189, 03191, 03197, 03198, 03199, 03216, 03217, 03218, 03231, 03232, 03234, 03235, 03236, 03238, 03239, 03240, 03241, 03242, 03243, 03244, 03245, 03246, 03247, 03248, 03249, 03250, 03251, 03252, 03254, 03255, 03256, 03257, 03258, 03259, 03260, 03261, 03264, 03265, 03266, 03267, 03268, 03269, 03270, 03320, 03351, 03352, 03353, 03355, 03362, 03364, 03365, 03369, 03370, 03375, 03378, 03380, 03381, 03393, 03394, 03395, 03430, 03478, 03486, 03487, 03489, 03535, 03536, 03553, 03554, 03555, 03558, 03559, 03560, 03564, 03565, 03567, 03569, 03571, 03573, 03574, 03605, 03612, 03613, 03615, 03616, 03617, 03618, 03619, 03697, 03705, 03706, 03707, 03708, 03710, 03711, 03712, 03713, 03714, 03715, 03716, 03717, 03718, 03719, 03720, 03721, 03722, 03723, 03724, 03725, 03726, 03727, 03728, 03729, 03730, 03731, 03732, 03733, 03734, 03735, 03736, 03738, 03739, 03757, 03758, 03760, 03765, 03767, 03768, 03769, 03774, 03777, 03782, 03783, 03784, 03785, 03790, 03797, 03807, 03808, 03809, 03810, 03811, 03812, 03813, 03814, 03819, 03820, 03821, 03822, 03823, 03824, 03840, 03847, 03848, 03849, 03851, 03854, 03856, 03857, 03868, 03869, 03871, 03894, 03895, 03992, 03995, 04015, 04020, 04035, 04038, 04042, 04044, 04046, 04050, 04051, 04053, 04057, 04058, 04059, 04060, 04061, 04062, 04076, 04077, 04079, 04083, 04084, 04085, 04087, 04088, 04089, 04091, 04092, 04094, 04095, 04096, 04097, 04098, 04099, 04100, 04101, 04102, 04103, 04105, 04106, 04107, 04108, 04109, 04110, 04111, 04113, 04114, 04115, 04116, 04118, 04119, 04120, 04121, 04123, 04124, 04125, 04126, 04127, 04129, 04130, 04131, 04132, 04134, 04135, 04137, 04138, 04139, 04141, 04142, 04143, 04144, 04145, 04146, 04147, 04148, 04149, 04150, 04152, 04153, 04154, 04155, 04156, 04157, 04158, 04159, 04161, 04162, 04164, 04165, 04166, 04167, 04168, 04171, 04172, 04173, 04174, 04264, 04271, 04276, 04283, 04290, 04297, 04298, 04299, 04300, 04307, 04310, 04311, 04317, 04318, 04319, 04323, 04324, 04328, 04330, 04332, 04333, 04342, 04345, 04350, 04351, 04352, 04353, 04354, 04355, 04356, 04357, 04358, 04359, 04360, 04361, 04362, 04363, 04364, 04365, 04366, 04367, 04368, 04369, 04371, 04374, 04390, 04394, 04401, 04402, 04410, 04411, 04412, 04413, 04513, 04517, 04518, 04519, 04520, 04521, 04522, 04525, 04526, 04527, 04700, 04785, 04796, 04798, 04801, 04806, 05008, 05009, 05048, 05128, 05194, 05207, 05208, 05209, 05211, 05212, 05213, 05214, 05215, 05216, 05217, 05218, 05219, 05220, 05221, 05222, 05223, 05224, 05225, 05226, 05227, 05229, 05231, 05237, 05269, 05280, 05330, 05332, 05333, 05336, 05338, 05340, 05342, 05346, 05348, 05352, 05357, 05364, 05365, 05367, 05370, 05371, 05373, 05377, 05378, 05381, 05384, 05386, 05387, 05388, 05389, 05392, 05402, 05412, 05425, 05427, 05428, 05429, 05432, 05434, 05435, 05436, 05437, 05438, 05439, 05440, 05441, 05442, 05463, 05464, 05467, 05469, 05470, 05471, 05472, 05473, 05477, 05479, 05510, 05535, 05542, 05544, 05545, 05550, 05562, 05568, 05569, 05570, 05571, 05572, 05573, 05574, 05577, 05589, 05590, 05594, 05596, 05599, 05672, 05673, 05674, 05675, 05676, 05677, 05678, 05679, 05680, 05681, 05682, 05683, 05684, 05685, 05686, 05687, 05688, 05689, 05690, 05691, 05692, 05693, 05724, 05758, 05759, 05760, 05776, 05780, 05782, 05783, 05787, 05799, 05802, 05808, 05828, 05851, 05858, 05918, 05920, 05921, 05922, 05923, 05924, 05937, 05940, 05948, 05962, 05966, 05968, 05971, 05972, 05973, 05974, 05987, 05988, 05995, 05996, 05998, 05999, 06013, 06014, 06015, 06045, 06048, 06056, 06060, 06067, 06112, 06129, 06150, 06172, 06179, 06194, 06215, 06220, 06222, 06223, 06239, 06241, 06242, 06243, 06288, 06289, 06292, 06302, 06329, 06331, 06355, 06356, 06357, 06358, 06359, 06360, 06361, 06362, 06363, 06364, 06365, 06366, 06367, 06368, 06369, 06370, 06371, 06387, 06388, 06390, 06391, 06392, 06393, 06394, 06395, 06398, 06416, 06422, 06423, 06451, 06488, 06489, 06490, 06494, 06502, 06565, 06566, 06567, 06568, 06569, 06570, 06571, 06572, 06573, 06574, 06585, 06587, 06588, 06590, 06594, 06595, 06601, 06604, 06607, 06608, 06609, 06617, 06669, 06670, 06671, 06672, 06673, 06674, 06675, 06676, 06677, 06697, 06698, 06714, 06742, 06743, 06745, 06751, 06752, 06755, 06756, 06757, 06758, 06760, 06761, 06762, 06763, 06764, 06765, 06766, 06767, 06768, 06769, 06770, 06771, 06772, 06773, 06774, 06775, 06776, 06777, 06778, 06779, 06780, 06781, 06782, 06785, 06786, 06801, 06805, 06806, 06807, 06809, 06810, 06811, 06812, 06813, 06825, 06826, 06827, 06839, 06851, 06854, 06882, 06898, 06917, 06922, 06931, 06932, 06943, 06946, 06949, 06950, 06987, 06999, 07001, 07017, 07021, 07022, 07023, 07092, 07101, 07109, 07119, 07121, 07122, 07123, 07131, 07134, 07135, 07136, 07137, 07138, 07139, 07140, 07141, 07142, 07143, 07144, 07145, 07146, 07147, 07148, 07149, 07150, 07151, 07152, 07153, 07154, 07155, 07156, 07157, 07158, 07159, 07160, 07213, 07222, 07224, 07233, 07234, 07245, 07246, 07251, 07252, 07316, 07361, 07372, 07456, 07458, 07476, 07482, 07500, 07513, 07587, 07589, 07591, 07592, 07607, 07633, 07652, 07657, 07662, 07664, 07667, 07728, 07729, 07730, 07732, 07733, 07734, 07735, 07736, 07737, 07738, 07739, 07740, 07741, 07742, 07743, 07744, 07745, 07746, 07747, 07748, 07749, 07750, 07751, 07752, 07753, 07767, 07768, 07769, 07774, 07779, 07782, 07783, 07787, 07804, 07805, 07806, 07807, 07808, 07809, 07810, 07811, 07812, 07813, 07814, 07815, 07816, 07817, 07818, 07819, 07820, 07821, 07826, 07827, 07828, 07829, 07830, 07831, 07832, 07833, 07860, 07862, 07863, 07864, 07865, 07866, 07867, 07872, 07873, 07874, 07875, 07877, 07878, 07879, 07880, 07881, 07882, 07883, 07884, 07885, 07887, 07888, 07889, 07890, 07891, 07892, 07893, 07894, 07895, 07898, 07899, 07902, 07907, 07908, 07912, 07914, 07917, 07918, 07919, 07920, 07921, 07922, 07946, 07947, 07948, 07949, 07950, 07951, 07952, 07953, 07954, 07955, 07957, 07958, 07959, 07963, 07965, 07967, 07968, 07969, 07970, 07971, 07972, 07973, 07974, 07975, 07977, 07978, 07983, 07985, 07989, 07990, 07992, 07993, 07995, 07998, 07999, 08001, 08002, 08007, 08008, 08009, 08010, 08011, 08012, 08013, 08014, 08015, 08016, 08037, 08071, 08072, 08073, 08074, 08081, 08082, 08083, 08084, 08086, 08087, 08091, 08093, 08095, 08097, 08098, 08099, 08100, 08101, 08102, 08104, 08107, 08108, 08111, 08113, 08114, 08116, 08131, 08138, 08140, 08142, 08143, 08150, 08162, 08186, 08203, 08206, 08209, 08210, 08211, 08213, 08214, 08215, 08216, 08219, 08220, 08224, 08227, 08228, 08230, 08240, 08243, 08244, 08245, 08246, 08247, 08248, 08255, 08256, 08257, 08259, 08260, 08261, 08263, 08264, 08267, 08269, 08344, 08359, 08363, 08365, 08366, 08368, 08369, 08370, 08371, 08372, 08377, 08386, 08388, 08390, 08391, 08392, 08393, 08394, 08395, 08396, 08397, 08398, 08399, 08400, 08402, 08403, 08405, 08406, 08407, 08408, 08409, 08410, 08411, 08412, 08413, 08414, 08415, 08416, 08418, 08419, 08420, 08421, 08422, 08423, 08424, 08425, 08426, 08427, 08428, 08429, 08432, 08457, 08458, 08459, 08464, 08465, 08466, 08468, 08473, 08477, 08478, 08481, 08484, 08491, 08506, 08507, 08569, 08585, 08588, 08589, 08590, 08591, 08592, 08593, 08594, 08595, 08596, 08597, 08598, 08599, 08600, 08601, 08602, 08603, 08604, 08605, 08606, 08607, 08608, 08609, 08610, 08611, 08612, 08613, 08614, 08615, 08616, 08617, 08618, 08619, 08620, 08621, 08622, 08623, 08624, 08625, 08626, 08627, 08628, 08629, 08630, 08631, 08632, 08633, 08634, 08635, 08636, 08637, 08689, 08707, 08717, 08738, 08739, 08740, 08741, 08743, 08745; e contrário às demais emendas. A bancada do PT - Partido dos Trabalhadores, composta pela Deputada Ana Perugini e pelos Deputados Luiz Cláudio Marcolino e Simão Pedro, apresentou voto em separado, favorável ao projeto, à emenda "A", às emendas relacionadas às subemendas nºs 1 a 10 ora apresentadas; e contrário às demais emendas, o qual foi devidamente lido pelos Deputados Luiz Cláudio Marcolino e Simão Pedro. Em discussão, fizeram uso da palavra as Senhoras Deputadas Ana Perugini, Regina Gonçalves e Vanessa Damo e os Senhores Deputados Luiz Cláudio Marcolino, Estevam Galvão, Carlos Bezerra, Orlando Bolçone e Simão Pedro. A Senhora Relatora, com a palavra, detalhou alguns pontos de seu relatório, a fim de dirimir as dúvidas levantadas. Em votação, foi aprovado como parecer o voto da Senhora Relatora. Votaram favoravelmente ao voto da Senhora Relatora as Senhoras Deputadas Regina Gonçalves, Maria Lúcia Amary e Vanessa Damo e os Senhores Deputados Alex Manente, Orlando Bolçone, Carlos Bezerra e o Senhor Presidente. Votaram favoravelmente ao voto em separado a Senhora Deputada Ana Perugini e os Senhores Deputados Luiz Cláudio Marcolino e Simão Pedro. O Senhor Presidente, antes de encerrar a reunião, cancelou a reunião extraordinária das 15:00 hs do mesmo dia e confirmou a realização da reunião extraordinária das 16:00 hs do mesmo dia, com a finalidade de deliberar sobre o voto do relator ao PPA - Plano Plurianual para o período 2012-2015, objeto do PL 771/11. Nada mais havendo a tratar, o Senhor Presidente deu por encerrada a reunião, que foi gravada pelo Serviço de Audiofonia e cuja ata eu, Sonia Maria Oliveira, Agente Técnico Legislativo, lavrei e assino após sua Excelência. Faz parte integrante desta Ata a transcrição da gravação dos trabalhos. Aprovada em reunião de 14/12/11, às 16:00 h. Deputado Mauro Bragato Presidente ATL Sonia Maria Oliveira Secretária